Re: [Dokter Umum] kampanye hitam anti imunisasi

terima kasih banyak untuk para dokter, pemerhati dan anggota millis,
saya jadi tambah banyak pengetahuan dan ilmu yang tadinya saya tidak
tahu...ini akan bisa jadi acuan, dan ukuran untuk bisa mengambil sikap
tentunya, walaupun secara tidak langsung telah terjadi adu argumen
tentang masalah ini di millis kita :)..tapi ilmu dan pengetahuan ini
sangat bermanfaaat untuk saya pribadi.. sekali lagi terima kasih
banyak untuk saran sarannya

2012/5/29, Dr.(Naturopathy) Ir. Donny Hosea MBA. PhD <puyuh23@indo.net.id>:
> Hello Dini,
> Iya benar, persoalanya bukan hitam atau putih, benar atau salah,
> mengikuti program atau tidak, melainkan bagaimana kita mengerti akan apa
> yg hendak dicapai, n bagaimana kita menajga putra putri kita dg asupan
> yg benar, yg membantu dia utk bisa mempersiapkan tubuhnya melawan
> serangan intruder baik virus, maupun bacteria dari luar tubuh.
> Kalau kita mengerti, kita care, kita preventive, tentu kita tidak perlu
> kuatir n protektive (pada hal belum tentu itu menghasilkan protective,
> bahkan mungkin menjadikanya down karena berbagai bahan terkandung).
> Dibalik vaccine terkandung berbagai makna, tdk sekedar single strain yg
> hendak kita rangsang utk ditimbulkan antibody tubuh sang anak, jadi
> bijaksana, mengerti, mengetahui, adalah hal yg penting dibanding sekedar
> yg penting sdh di vaccine, seolah vaccine adalah jaminan pasti.
> So, selamat, anak anda terhindar dari conspirasi n diberi kesempatan utk
> hidup layak secara natural sebagai manusia, sesuai dg semboyan anda: "
> Yang kita butuhkan adalah sistem imun yang kuat ".
>
> Salam,
>
> On 5/28/2012 10:57 PM, Dini Aprilia wrote:
>> Halo Pak Dio, rekan2, dan dokter2,
>>
>> Saya adalah seorang Ibu dari anak usia 13 bulan. Dulu saya juga sempat
>> merasakan dilematis amat sangat perihal vaksin. Surely sebagai orangtua
>> kita ingin berikan/lakukan yang terbaik untuk buah hati kita. Setiap
>> pilihan yang diambil (karena anak belum bisa memutuskan) tentunya adalah
>> hak dan sekaligus tanggung jawab orangtua yang bersangkutan. Tidak boleh
>> ada paksaan dari siapapun. Dan setiap orang hendaknya dapat menghargai
>> pilihan orang lain yang berbeda.
>>
>> Sekedar sharing, saya dan suami akhirnya memutuskan untuk menghentikan
>> vaksinasi anak saya.
>> Dalam perjalanannya (sebelum memutuskan), saya sempat dilanda rasa
>> khawatir/takut. Jika terus vaksin, saya takut anak saya autis/KIPI parah,
>> di sisi lain jika tidak vaksin saya takut anak saya terkena penyakit
>> infeksi yang sebenarnya bisa dicegah.
>> Kemudian saya sadar, rasa takut bukanlah landasan yang baik dalam
>> decision
>> making.
>>
>> Berikut ini saya kutipkan saran dari sebuah artikel berjudul "Make your
>> Vaccination Decisions from Your Core Values not Fear" (
>> http://healthychild.com/healthy-kids-blog/make-your-vaccination-decisions-from-your-core-values-not-fear/
>> )
>> "First, gather the information available in regards to the decision at
>> hand.
>> Then, put all of it aside and recognize the core of your own beliefs.
>> Once identified with these life principles, weigh your choices from this
>> place of knowing.
>> Choose from a state of trust and conviction consistent with these
>> essential
>> values.
>> They are the connection to your strength. From this place of certainty,
>> you
>> will always choose correctly."
>>
>> Saya percaya proses alami. Bayi yang baru lahir belum memiliki sistem
>> imun
>> yang mature, namun akan terus berkembang hingga mature pada usia di atas
>> 2
>> tahun.
>> Menurut pemahaman saya, sistem imun manusia bagaikan pasukan pertahanan
>> yang menjaga sebuah kota, terdiri dari beberapa lapis pertahanan. Sebelum
>> musuh dapat memasuki dan menduduki kota, mereka harus melewati halangan
>> dan
>> rintangan fisik, serta mengalahkan pasukan2 di garis terluar/depan
>> dahulu.
>> Dengan berhadapan dengan musuh di garis depan, maka pasukan dapat
>> menginformasikan ke pusat mengenai serangan musuh (siapa musuhnya, berapa
>> banyak dsb). Informasi tersebut akan diproses untuk mengantisipasi
>> kuatnya
>> serangan, jenis senjata yang cocok, berapa banyak amunisi, berapa banyak
>> pasukan tambahan dsb.
>> Jika pasukan di garis depan tidak mampu menahan serangan, dinyalakanlah
>> alarm peringatan. Pasukan di dalam sudah siap dengan senjatanya yang
>> disiapkan spesifik untuk menghadapi musuh tersebut.
>>
>> Apa yang terjadi jika bayi disuntik vaksin (antigen+chemicals)?
>> Ide awalnya memang agar tubuh menghasilkan antibodi dengan cara
>> mengenalkan
>> antigen (dilemahkan). Akan tetapi rute masuknya antigen tersebut berbeda
>> dengan rute masuknya bibit penyakit secara alami (yang akan melewati
>> beberapa lapis pertahanan).
>> Analoginya adalah Kuda Troya pada perang Troya.
>> "Pada Perang Troya, para prajurit Yunani bersembunyi di dalam Kuda
>> Troya<http://id.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kuda_Troya> yang
>> berukuran raksasa yang ditujukan sebagai pengabdian kepada
>> Poseidon<http://id.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poseidon>.
>> Kuda Troya tersebut menurut para petinggi Troya dianggap tidak berbahaya,
>> dan diizinkan masuk ke dalam benteng Troya yang tidak dapat ditembus oleh
>> para prajurit Yunani selama kurang lebih 10 tahun perang Troya
>> bergejolak.
>> Pada malam harinya, pasukan Yunani keluar dari perut kuda kayu tersebut
>> dan
>> akhirnya merebut kota Troya." (Wikipedia).
>>
>> Bagaimana dengan bahan2 kimia yang terkandung dalam vaksin? Meski dalam
>> jumlah minimal, tetap saja bahan2 kimia tersebut disuntikkan pada seorang
>> bayi. Hati dan ginjalnya belum sempurna untuk memetabolisasi bahan kimia
>> berbahaya. Bukankah untuk MPASI bayi saja kita menghindari instant food,
>> additives, MSG, bahkan gula dan garam?
>>
>> Jadi, saya dan suami pada akhirnya memilih untuk menghentikan vaksinasi
>> anak kami, dan memberikan kesempatan sistem imunnya tumbuh matang dengan
>> baik. Sistem imun anak akan terus mendapat tantangan, misalnya ketika
>> memasuki fase oral. Ketika masih infant, peralatan minum/breast pump
>> harus
>> selalu disterilisasi, namun kini peralatan makan minum anak saya hanya
>> dicuci biasa.
>>
>> Dengan tidak vaksin, bukan berarti lantas kami berdiam diri. Tentu saja
>> kami juga melakukan usaha2 dalam meningkatkan respon imunnya dengan
>> memberikan ASI semau bayi, MPASI alami dan sehat, juga suplemen yang
>> bersifat alami (misalnya madu, VCO, propolis, dsb).
>>
>> Teman saya pernah bertanya, dengan tidak vaksin apakah saya tidak takut
>> dengan banyaknya penyakit2 baru di zaman modern ini?
>> Justru karena banyak penyakit baru, apakah harus selalu vaksin? akan
>> terdapat banyak sekali vaksin. Satu penyakit saja strain bibit
>> penyakitnya
>> bisa banyak. Yang kita butuhkan adalah sistem imun yang kuat.
>>
>> Dulu saya sempat bersitegang dengan orangtua saya sendiri perihal
>> keputusan
>> saya dan suami. Namun akhirnya kami sepakat untuk tidak
>> mengungkit-ungkit.
>> Dan mungkin sekarang mereka bisa lihat sendiri, anak saya bisa dibilang
>> cukup tangguh. Mertua saya (pengelola apotek) pun heran karena anak saya
>> tidak pernah sakit, even batuk pilek dan mencret.
>>
>> Demikian sharing saya. Semoga bisa memberikan sudut pandang lain. Silakan
>> saja jika Anda tidak sependapat dengan saya, itu hak Anda, dan saya
>> menghargainya.
>>
>> Mohon maaf jika ada kalimat yang kurang berkenan, saya tidak bermaksud
>> 'menyerang' siapapun.
>>
>> Salam,
>> Dini A. Murdeani
>>
>> ----------------------
>> Copy paste dari link artikel di atas:
>>
>> Make your Vaccination Decisions from Your Core Values not Fear
>> NOVEMBER 15, 2011 BY JANE
>> SHEPPARD<http://healthychild.com/healthy-kids-blog/author/Jane%20Sheppard/>
>> LEAVE A
>> COMMENT<http://healthychild.com/healthy-kids-blog/make-your-vaccination-decisions-from-your-core-values-not-fear/#comments>
>>
>> I read Jeanne Ohm's editorial in a Pathways issue and feel compelled to
>> post it here. It's the wisest advice I've ever read about the vaccination
>> issue. Pathways is a great magazine for parents, providing excellent
>> articles and vital resources for family wellness. You can subscribe to
>> Pathways at this link:
>> http://www.pathwaystofamilywellness.org
>> Lettter from the Editor: Pathways Issue 22
>>
>> Jeanne Ohm, DC
>> [image: Vaccination
>> Decisions]<http://healthychild.com/healthy-kids-blog/wp-content/uploads/2011/11/iStock_000011177104XSmall.jpg>Make
>> your Vaccination Decisions from Your Core Values Instead of Fear
>>
>> Several weeks ago, a father in our practice said to me, "I'm afraid not
>> to
>> vaccinate, and I'm just as afraid to vaccinate." My response was not to
>> address the list of pros and cons on either side of the vaccination
>> issue.
>> My response was to have him take two steps back, and understand that any
>> choice made from fear is made from a skewed perspective and would be
>> unproductive and unstable. Rather than building on this unstable
>> foundation
>> created by fear, it was more important that he define his core values in
>> life-those essential values from which all of his decisions could be
>> made.
>> Once defined, he would be making a decision from a place of certainty and
>> trust.
>>
>> Essentially, there are two perspectives about healing. One is
>> mechanistic-it defines life as a random series of events, devoid of an
>> organized and intelligent purpose. Sickness is to be treated, symptoms
>> are
>> to be eliminated, and the body needs expert opinions based on human
>> knowledge to help it heal. The other is vitalistic. It recognizes,
>> respects, and trusts in the intelligence of life and the
>> interconnectedness
>> of this wisdom among all life. Processes of the body are to be trusted,
>> not
>> feared, and an underlying confidence for healing and proper function is
>> emphasized. Hippocrates, the father of medicine summed up the heart of
>> this
>> perspective well, "Humans are created to be healthy as long as they are
>> whole: body, mind, spirit." People are characterized by self-healing
>> properties that come from within-an innate healing force. Perfect health
>> and harmony is the normal state for all life.
>>
>> It is imperative that we define our core values and consciously make our
>> life and health choices from the perspective which resonates best with
>> those values. It is also imperative that we choose practitioners who base
>> their choices on the same foundation.
>>
>> In Pathways, we offer the perspective of vitalism-the confidence of an
>> inherent intelligence that sustains our very existence. Our articles
>> introduce principles built on this foundation, in the hope that parents
>> will recognize and resonate with it. Shifting to this paradigm is
>> sometimes
>> challenging, especially since the majority of health care, news media,
>> laws, and regulations do not support this perspective. It is hard to go
>> against what seems to be the grain, and we are often met with resistance,
>> opposition, and outright criticism, laced with fear and even
>> intimidation.
>> That powerful emotion-fear-then becomes the motivating factor in our
>> decisions. But fear is too unstable an emotion from which to make any
>> good
>> choices. I am reminded of the quote from Bertrand Russell: "Collective
>> fear
>> stimulates herd instinct, and tends to produce ferocity toward those who
>> are not regarded as members of the herd."
>>
>> In 30 years of making life and health choices for our family, my husband
>> and I have heard all of the arguments used to challenge our vitalistic
>> core
>> beliefs. When we started having our family, there was little to no
>> scientific evidence on natural birthing, co-sleeping, long-term
>> breastfeeding, vaccination risks, and the refusal of drugs for
>> symptomatic
>> relief. We were labeled irresponsible at best. We were told our beliefs
>> had
>> no scientific validation.
>>
>> To us, credibility did not come from this scientific perspective devoid
>> of
>> any recognition of vitalism. Our validation came along the lines of an
>> emerging science-one less known, and only sparsely integrated into the
>> healing arts. Max Planck, Nobel Prize-winning physicist and the father of
>> quantum theory, acknowledged this new science well in a 1944 speech: "All
>> matter originates and exists only by virtue of a force…. We must assume
>> behind this force the existence of a conscious and intelligent mind. This
>> mind is the matrix of all matter."
>>
>> Since then, and now in the 21st century, the relationship between this
>> emerging science and health is becoming more accepted. Although promoted
>> over 100 years ago by the founder of chiropractic, D.D. Palmer, the
>> recognition and practice of health care from an inherent trust of our
>> amalgamation with a greater intelligence is finally emerging. Dr. Deepak
>> Chopra sums up this perspective well: "There is an inner intelligence in
>> your body, and that inner intelligence is consciousness. It's the
>> ultimate
>> in supreme genius, which mirrors the wisdom of the universe."
>>
>> As for the father and what he chose for his child-I don't know for sure.
>> I
>> do know, however, that he understood the importance in parenting of
>> connecting with his wife, going within, and embracing what they know to
>> be
>> true. My appeal to all parents when making life and health choices for
>> their families is to do the same. First, gather the information available
>> in regards to the decision at hand. Then, put all of it aside and
>> recognize
>> the core of your own beliefs. Once identified with these life principles,
>> weigh your choices from this place of knowing. Choose from a state of
>> trust
>> and conviction consistent with these essential values. They are the
>> connection to your strength. From this place of certainty, you will
>> always
>> choose correctly.
>>
>>
>> [Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
>>
>
> --
> We care human as human not as sickness object --
> "Absolutely Drug less Health Care solution Organization"
>
>


------------------------------------

[ Forum Kesehatan : http://www.medisiana.com ]Yahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/dokter_umum/

<*> Your email settings:
Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/dokter_umum/join
(Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
dokter_umum-digest@yahoogroups.com
dokter_umum-fullfeatured@yahoogroups.com

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
dokter_umum-unsubscribe@yahoogroups.com

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/